Which Is Right?
I’m often asking the question, “Which is the right way to do a swing?” The same holds true for snatches and cleans, and a great many things.
There are a variety of ways you can do some exercises. This doesn’t mean the mechanics are compromised it simply means there are variations. Variations are good! (provided proper mechanics are maintained.)
Let’s talk about kettlebells today.
I teach different variations of exercises to different types of people. I also chose to know and be able to teach different variations of certain exercises because one variation might be more applicable to a certain sport, why another variation might be easier for someone to pick up and perform properly.
We cover these two different variations of snatches, cleans, and high pulls quite well in the Kettlebell Athletics certification as well as at Urban Athlete and any training workshop.
One is a vertical path, where the kettlebell starts either from the floor or from the hang position, just below the knees and travels in a vertical path to it’s ending point, overhead in a snatch, to the rack position in a clean or to chest height in high pulls.
This variation more directly mimics Olympic weight lifting and is very applicable to sports training.
The other variation, we call curvi-linear, where the kettlebell hikes back behind your hips for each movement, the snatch, clean, and high pulls just as it does with a swing. In this variation slightly more momentum is used, and the kettlebell always gets hiked back behind the hips.
I like to teach and use both variations myself. From here there are also more advanced variations that come from following the vertical path, which I will talk about later on.
There’s also a variation from girevoy sport, which is more similar to the curvi-linear variation but has the goal of conserving energy, as these competition sets are aimed to get extremely high repetitions in a ten minute time period with only one hans switch and not putting the kettlebell down.
As long as proper body mechanics are maintained you can use many variations. Just remember that bad form is not a variation.